Can Creative Agencies Survive Without Retainers in 2025?

For years, retainers were the holy grail of agency life. They promised predictable cash flow, deeper client relationships, and the stability to build teams without constantly chasing the next sale. But here's what's happening right now: more clients are walking away from retainers entirely.

They want agility. They want control. They want to pay for what they actually need, when they need it.

The question isn't whether this shift is happening.

It's whether your agency can survive it. And more importantly, whether you should even try to fight it.

What's Driving the Death of Retainers?

Client Budget Pressure

Let's be brutally honest about the current economic climate. UK agencies are facing clients who are tightening their purse strings like never before. Post-pandemic budget constraints haven't disappeared—they've evolved into a permanent state of financial caution.

Clients aren't just asking for better value anymore. They're demanding it. They want accountability, measurable outcomes, and the ability to switch directions without being locked into six-month commitments that feel increasingly obsolete.

The Speed of Modern Marketing

Think about it: when campaigns used to run for months, retainers made sense. But now? TikTok trends last days. Instagram algorithm changes happen overnight. Performance marketing campaigns can be optimised and pivoted within hours.

Clients need agencies who can move as fast as their markets do. And frankly, many retainer structures are built for a slower world that no longer exists.

The Rise of the DIY Client

Here's the uncomfortable truth no one wants to talk about: clients are getting better at doing things themselves. Canva didn't just democratise design, it fundamentally changed client expectations about what requires an agency.

They're supplementing with freelancers for routine work, using internal teams for basic campaigns, and only calling agencies for the complex stuff. Which means they need you less often, but they need you to be exceptional when they do.

The Financial Reality of Losing Retainers

Cash Flow Becomes Your Enemy

Without retainers, you're back to the feast-or-famine cycle that kills agencies. One month you're flush with project payments, the next you're scrambling to cover payroll. Aside from this being stressful, it’s also dangerous.

You can't make smart hiring decisions when you don't know what revenue looks like next quarter. You can't invest in systems, training, or growth when every penny is accounted for in immediate expenses.

Lower Margins Are Inevitable

Project work has a dirty secret: it almost always gets underpriced and over-serviced. Clients pushback on scope creep more aggressively on projects because they're paying specifically for deliverables, not relationships.

Your team ends up doing more work than quoted because "it's just a few tweaks" or "the client seemed frustrated." These seemingly small margin erosions compound fast, especially when you factor in the hidden costs of constant client onboarding and communication.

The Client Concentration Trap

To replace one £10k/month retainer, you need ten £1k projects. That's ten times the sales meetings, ten times the proposals, ten times the kick-off calls, and ten times the risk of delayed payments.

It's not just more work. It's exponentially more complex to manage. And if three of those projects get cancelled or delayed? Your entire month's revenue disappears overnight.

Can Agencies Make Projects Work? Absolutely—But Only With Ruthless Discipline

Systemise Everything

Stop treating every project like a bespoke masterpiece. Create repeatable, systemised service packages with fixed scopes, fixed prices, and fixed timelines. Think McDonald's, not Michelin stars.

Your website audit should follow the exact same process every time. Your brand strategy workshop should have a standardised agenda. Your social media packages should have clearly defined deliverables.

When everything is systematised, projects become profitable. When they're bespoke, they become bleeding wounds.

Redefine Your Minimum Engagement

Here's a radical thought: what if you refused to work on anything under £5k? Or £10k?

Create minimum engagement thresholds that force clients into meaningful commitments. Hybrid models work brilliantly—quarterly contracts, rolling three-month scopes, or "flexible retainers" that give clients the control they want while giving you the predictability you need.

Engineer Your Cash Flow

Build payment terms that frontload cash. 50% upfront, 30% at the halfway point, 20% on completion. Net 30 becomes Net 15. New clients pay 100% upfront until they've completed three successful projects.

Yes, some clients will push back. Let them. The clients who value your work will pay your terms. The ones who don't aren't the clients you need.

Design the Client Journey

Every project should be designed to lead to the next one. Your website audit should reveal content strategy needs. Your content strategy should uncover social media gaps. Your social media audit should identify paid advertising opportunities.

Stop thinking in projects and start thinking in client lifecycles. The best project-based agencies don't just deliver work—they architect ongoing relationships.

The Rise of Retainer 2.0

The future isn't necessarily project-only. It's smarter retainers.

Outcome-based retainers tie your fee to client results, not hours logged. 

Advisory retainers position you as a strategic growth partner, not just a service provider. 

Community models create recurring revenue through access to your expertise, not just your execution.

These models give clients the flexibility they're demanding while giving you the predictability you need to grow sustainably.

Your Agency Will Survive 

Can agencies survive without traditional retainers? Of course. Many already have.

The real question is whether you can build a sustainable, profitable, strategic business without them. And the answer is yes—but only if you're willing to completely reimagine how you price, structure, and deliver your services.

The agencies that will thrive in 2025 aren't the ones doing the most work. They're the ones with the most predictable business models, the clearest value propositions, and the strongest financial discipline.

The retainer model is evolving. And your agency's future depends on whether you evolve with it or get left behind scrambling for the next project.

The choice is yours. But whatever you choose, choose with intention, structure, and a clear financial plan. 

Because in 2025, hope isn't a strategy—predictability is.

‍