Why Larger Agencies Are Scaling While Smaller Ones Are Stalling

I’m going to be honest – the agency world is splitting into two camps in 2025.

Some agencies are crushing it. They’re scaling operations, boosting profit margins, and building serious business value. Others are stuck in permanent survival mode, hustling 24/7 but going nowhere fast.

And it's not about size or talent. It's about structure and mindset.

Two Very Different Agencies

Picture Agency A: 22 team members, clear service offerings, and a finance function that gives them real-time visibility into their numbers. They've built proper systems for sales, client management, and delivery. They plan quarters ahead. They know exactly where their money comes from and goes to.

Then there's Agency B: Been grinding for four years, bouncing between 3-7 people depending on cashflow, constantly chasing the next project, with the founder handling everything from sales calls to QA. They're working harder but building nothing sustainable.

I see this split every day. Some smaller agencies remain "young, unprofessional, hit-or-miss." 

All talent, zero structure.

Why Larger Agencies Are Scaling in 2025

1. They Have Systems

This is the foundation. Mature agencies don't reinvent the wheel with every client. They've built:

• Documented client onboarding processes
• Clear project management frameworks
• Standardised reporting templates
• Defined escalation procedures
• Consistent invoicing and collection systems

These aren't sexy. Nobody's posting about their "awesome client onboarding workflow" on LinkedIn. But this operational maturity separates professionals from amateurs.

Systems reduce friction, increase client trust, and free up leadership to focus on growth rather than firefighting.

2. They Hire Strategically

Scaling agencies understand the power of specialists. They don't just hire generalists or expect founders to do everything.

They invest in:

• Skilled operators who execute consistently
• Finance professionals who provide actionable insights
• Account managers who own client relationships
• Department leads who drive quality and innovation

Each role has clear responsibilities, metrics, and accountability. The business doesn't collapse when one person is unavailable.

3. They Play the Long Game

This is massive. Mature agencies focus on profit over vanity metrics. They think in terms of:

• 10-year client value vs. quick project cash
• Building intellectual property and repeatable services
• Creating assets that appreciate over time

They don't panic during temporary slowdowns. Instead, they plan and pivot strategically. They decline projects that don't align with their positioning, even when cash would be nice.

Why Small Agencies Stall (and Sometimes Implode)

1. Hustle Culture Overload

Everything's urgent. Everything's reactive. The founder is constantly firefighting.

They're proud of "how much they get done," but they're never building systems that scale. They're just sprinting on a hamster wheel.

The result? Founders lack the mental bandwidth to think critically about growth. Their entire capacity is consumed just keeping the lights on.

2. Poor Client Experience

When you're constantly scrambling, clients feel it. Missed deadlines. Poor communication. Overpromising and underdelivering.

Even with good creative work, the overall experience makes clients feel unsafe. And unsafe clients don't stick around or refer others.

This creates a vicious cycle of churn, forcing more desperate business development, leading to bad-fit clients, causing more churn...

3. Transactional Thinking

Small, stalling agencies get stuck in transaction mode—chasing quick cash versus building assets, processes, and brand equity.

They have zero positioning—just a generic "we do everything" pitch that attracts price-sensitive clients who view creative services as commodities.

They can't command premium rates without established authority. They can't build deep expertise while constantly switching between different industries and services.

What Growing Agencies Can Learn from the Big Players

It's not about headcount, it's about headspace.

Agencies can be small in team size but operate with the professionalism and confidence of much larger firms. I've seen 5-person shops run more effectively than some 30-person operations.

Maturity looks like:

• A defined niche or ideal client profile
• Operational dashboards tracking key metrics
• Proper financial planning beyond revenue chasing
• Standardised delivery frameworks
• Dedicated time for strategy and innovation

The Path to Stability: Transitioning from Reactive to Respected

1. Build Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs)

Even with just three people—operate like a 30-person shop.

Document your:

• Client onboarding process
• Project kickoff framework
• Feedback and revision procedures
• Reporting templates
• Invoicing and collections

This isn't bureaucracy. It's professionalism that creates consistency and builds client confidence.

2. Decide Your Lane

Get ruthless about what you don't do. This is harder than defining what you do.

Positioning breeds authority. When you specialise in specific:

• Industries (e.g., fintech, healthcare)
• Services (e.g., conversion rate optimisation, brand strategy)
• Client sizes (e.g., Series A startups, enterprise)

You become the obvious choice for that specific need. You can charge more, work more efficiently, and build deeper expertise.

3. Start Measuring What Matters

Look beyond surface metrics. Track:

• Average client lifetime value
• Project profitability (not just revenue)
• Client retention rates
• Days sales outstanding
• Utilisation rates for billable staff
• Marketing ROI across channels

These numbers reveal if you're building a sustainable business—not just generating activity.

Are You Building a Business or a Freelance Machine?

The hard truth: If you disappeared, would the agency stop functioning?

If yes—you're not scaling, you're just sprinting in circles.

Building a true business means creating something that operates without you being involved in every decision and deliverable.

This doesn't mean stepping away completely. It means building something with value beyond your personal output.

Scaling Is a Mindset

Mature agencies win by choosing repeatable systems over heroic effort. They invest in processes, people, and positioning that enable strategic growth rather than chaotic expansion.

You can stay small but you must grow up. A boutique agency with clear positioning, solid operations, and healthy margins is infinitely more valuable than a larger shop running on chaos and burnout.

The agencies thriving in 2025 aren't necessarily the biggest or flashiest. They're the ones that have built solid foundations for sustainable growth.

Ready to shift from survival mode to strategic growth? Read this next if you have a startup.

‍