What if You Disagree with an HMRC Tax Decision or Penalty?

Getting a letter from HMRC with a tax bill or penalty you disagree with can feel like a punch to the gut. Your first instinct might be to panic or just pay up to make it go away. But here's something you need to know: HMRC isn't infallible, and you have more power than you think.

I've helped countless agency owners challenge HMRC decisions over the years, and I can tell you that many of these disputes are winnable when you know what you're doing. The key is understanding your rights, following the correct procedures, and building a strong case.

Can You Really Challenge HMRC?

Absolutely, yes. HMRC makes mistakes just like any other organisation. In fact, their own statistics show that thousands of appeals are successful every year.

You can challenge decisions about Income Tax assessments, Corporation Tax bills, VAT assessments and penalties, denied tax reliefs including R&D credits, Construction Industry Scheme decisions, penalties for late filing or late payments, requests to inspect your business records, and interest charges on overdue payments.

The important thing to remember is that HMRC's initial decision isn't final. They have internal review processes specifically designed to correct errors, and beyond that, there's an independent tribunal system that can overrule them completely.

Know Your Time Limits

Time is critical when it comes to HMRC appeals. The standard deadline is 30 days from the date of their decision letter, not from when you received it, but from the date printed on the letter itself.

Missing this deadline doesn't automatically mean game over, but it makes things significantly harder. HMRC will only accept late appeals if you can demonstrate a "reasonable excuse" for the delay. Examples of acceptable excuses include:

• Serious illness requiring hospitalisation
• Death of a close family member
• Postal strikes or severe weather preventing delivery
• Professional adviser's serious illness or death
• Fire, flood, or theft affecting your records

What doesn't count as a reasonable excuse:

• Being too busy with work
• Simply forgetting about the deadline
• Not understanding the implications
• Financial difficulties
• Relying on someone else to handle it (unless there were exceptional circumstances)

What Happens When You Submit an Appeal?

When you appeal an HMRC decision, you're essentially asking them to look at your case again. The process is more collaborative than confrontational, especially in the early stages.

The original decision maker will review your appeal first. They can accept your appeal completely, which happens more often than you might think, especially when you provide new information they didn't have originally. They might accept your appeal partially, agreeing you're partially right and adjusting the figures accordingly. They could reject your appeal entirely but offer you a statutory review or direct access to the tribunal. Sometimes they'll ask for more information if they need additional evidence to properly consider your case.

The Statutory Review Option

If HMRC doesn't accept your appeal, they'll offer you a statutory review. This is handled by a different HMRC officer who wasn't involved in the original decision, essentially giving you a fresh pair of eyes on your case.

The review process typically takes 45 days, though this can be extended if both parties agree. The reviewing officer will examine all the evidence from scratch, consider any new information you provide, look at whether the original decision maker applied the law correctly, and check if the decision was reasonable based on the available evidence.

I always recommend taking the review option first because it's free, faster than a tribunal, has quite a good success rate when you have solid grounds, you can still go to tribunal if the review doesn't go your way, and HMRC reviewers are often more pragmatic than the original decision makers.

Building Your Case: What Evidence Do You Need?

The strength of your appeal depends heavily on the evidence you can provide. HMRC decisions are usually based on the information they have at the time, so new or overlooked evidence can be game-changing.

For Tax Assessments

If you're challenging a tax assessment, you'll need to demonstrate that HMRC made a calculation error, they didn't consider all relevant information, they misapplied the tax law, or you have additional evidence that changes the position.

Essential documentation includes complete accounting records for the relevant period, bank statements showing all transactions, invoices and receipts and expense records, previous tax returns and correspondence, professional advice you relied upon, and any contracts or agreements affecting the tax position.

For Penalties

Penalty appeals often hinge on whether you have a "reasonable excuse" for missing a deadline or requirement. The law sets quite a high bar here – the excuse must be something that would prevent a reasonable person in your position from complying.

Strong reasonable excuse arguments include unexpected serious illness with medical evidence, system failures beyond your control with evidence from your software provider, exceptional personal circumstances with supporting documentation, and reliance on professional advice that was incorrect through no fault of yours.

Weak arguments that rarely succeed include pressure of work or being busy, lack of funds to pay the tax, misunderstanding the requirements, staff holidays or absences, and computer problems that could have been foreseen.

For VAT Disputes

VAT appeals often involve complex questions about the correct treatment of specific transactions. Common areas include whether supplies are standard-rated, reduced-rated, or exempt, the correct VAT treatment of international transactions, input tax recovery on mixed supplies, and the application of specific VAT schemes.

The key is demonstrating either that HMRC has misunderstood the nature of your business or transactions, or that they've applied the wrong VAT rules.

Special Considerations for Different Types of Appeals

Corporation Tax and R&D Credits

We see a lot of R&D credit disputes with our agency clients. HMRC's technical teams sometimes take a narrow view of what qualifies as R&D, particularly for software development projects.

If your R&D claim has been rejected, strong appeal evidence includes detailed project documentation showing the technical uncertainties you faced, evidence of the systematic approach you took to resolve them, documentation of failed attempts and iterations, technical expert opinions, and contemporaneous records of the development process.

Self Assessment Penalties

Self Assessment penalty appeals are often about timing and reasonable excuse. The most common scenarios we see are late filing penalties when the return was actually submitted on time but the system failed, late payment penalties when payment was made but not allocated correctly, and penalties applied despite having a payment plan in place.

For these appeals, bank statements showing payment dates and system screenshots can be crucial evidence.

VAT Default Surcharges

VAT default surcharges can escalate quickly, but they're often successfully appealed if you can show the late payment was due to exceptional circumstances, you normally have a good compliance record, or the default was caused by HMRC's own errors or delays.

The Tribunal Route: When to Consider It

If the review process doesn't resolve your dispute, you can appeal to the Tax Tribunal. This is an independent body that can overrule HMRC completely.

The process is designed to be accessible, with simplified procedures for smaller claims. For basic rate appeals, you can represent yourself quite effectively if you're well prepared. Appeals from the First-tier Tribunal go to the Upper Tribunal, but only on points of law. This is definitely specialist territory requiring professional representation.

One important consideration is costs. While the tribunal itself doesn't charge fees, you could be liable for HMRC's costs if you lose and your case was clearly hopeless. This is rare in practice, but it's a risk to be aware of.

Practical Tips for a Successful Appeal

1. Act quickly and don't wait until the last minute to appeal. You'll need time to gather evidence and prepare your case properly.
2. Be specific in your complaints. Vague statements like "the assessment is too high" won't get you far. Explain exactly what HMRC got wrong and provide the correct figures with supporting calculations.
3. Stay professional throughout the process. Emotional appeals or personal attacks on HMRC staff will undermine your case. Stick to the facts and the law.
4. Provide context to help HMRC understand your business and the circumstances that led to the issue. Context can be crucial, especially in penalty appeals.
5. Keep detailed records and document everything: when you sent correspondence, who you spoke to, what was discussed. This can be vital if things go to tribunal.
6. Consider settlement options. Sometimes a partial settlement is better than fighting to the bitter end. Be realistic about your chances and the costs involved.

Common Mistakes That Weaken Appeals

1. Incomplete evidence is a major problem. Don't assume HMRC will ask for what they need. Provide comprehensive evidence upfront.
2. Missing deadlines is the most common reason appeals fail before they even get started.
3. Inconsistent positions can undermine your case. Make sure your appeal is consistent with positions you've taken in other tax matters.
4. Ignoring HMRC's questions during the appeal process is counterproductive. If HMRC asks for additional information, respond promptly and completely.
5. Having unrealistic expectations about outcomes can lead to poor decisions. Some decisions, while frustrating, are legally correct. Focus your energy on winnable battles.

Now You Know

If you're facing an HMRC decision you disagree with, don't panic because you have rights and options. Check the deadline as you typically have 30 days to appeal. Gather your evidence by collecting all relevant documentation. Consider getting help, especially for complex cases or large amounts. Submit your appeal and don't let the deadline pass while you're still thinking about it.

Remember, HMRC's initial decision isn't the final word. With the right approach and proper evidence, many disputes can be resolved in your favour.

How Sidekick Can Help

At Sidekick, we've successfully handled hundreds of HMRC appeals for clients. We understand both the technical tax issues that agencies face and the practical aspects of building winning appeals.

Our approach combines deep knowledge of tax law and HMRC procedures, understanding of agency business models and common issues, experience with what arguments work and what don't, and practical project management to keep appeals on track.

Whether you're dealing with a penalty you think is unfair, a tax assessment that seems wrong, or a rejected R&D claim, we can help you understand your options and fight your corner effectively. 

Don't let HMRC decisions go unchallenged when you have good grounds to appeal.

‍